Chef Leah Caplan

That’s Italian Antipasto Platter

Delicious party platters to make entertaining in style easy. Metcalfe’s culinary team is committed to making sure that every item we prepare will look great and taste as impressive as your event, whether it’s a box lunch meeting, intimate dinner party, wedding, or anything in-between. Plus, we pride ourselves on using local, sustainable and organic products whenever possible. Your guests will taste the Metcalfe’s difference.

If a custom menu is what you are looking for, then you’ve come to the right place. Custom orders are our specialty! Just give us the details and we’ll help you create a menu that will tickle your taste buds and your budget.

All orders require a 48-hour notice and $25 minimum order
Madison 608.236.2033
Wauwatosa 414.259.8560
West Towne 608.829.3500

DELIVERY: $12.95

Click here to view Metcalfe’s Party Platters!

Click here to view Kids Party Menu!

Metcalfe’s Parties

White Bean & Chicken Chili
Angus Beef Chili
Nacho Bar (beans, guacamole, cheese sauce, sour cream and salsa)
Pineapple & Melon Platter

$15.00 per person

Elegant Cocktail Party
Apple Brie Bites
Toasted Pecan Squash Puffs
Mini Beef Wellingtons
Artichoke Parmesan Crostini
Wisconsin Cheese Platter with Fruits, Nuts, Chutney and Potter’s Crackers
Salumi and Vegetable Relishes
Crudités with Pesto and Sundried Tomato Dips
Strawberries, Macaroons and Brownies

$27.00 per person

Antipasto Platter
Lasagna (Vegetable & Meat)
Caesar Salad
Garlic Bread
Mini Cannoli

$15.00 per person

Casual Entertaining
Chipotle Chicken Spirals
Lemon Zucchini Pasta Salad
Kale & Apple Salad
Carl’s Mini Cupcakes

$15.00 per person

Casual Entertaining II
Assorted Wraps
Pasqual’s Chips and Salsa
Crudite & Dip
Platter of Finger Sweets

$10.00 per person

*All above parties require a minimum of 10 people.

Metcalfe’s à la Carte Hors d’Oeuvres

Dijon & Dill Deviled New Century Farm Organic Eggs $1
Chipotle Chicken Spirals $2.50
Spiced Chick Pea & Spinach Wraps $2.50
Wisconsin Artisan Cheese Platter with Cranberry Quince and Walnut Conserve, Dried Fruit, Nuts, Crackers (50 -75 servings) $200
Farmers Market Caponata, Metcalfe’s Housemade Mozzarella & Crostini Platter (50-75 servings) $150
Turkey & Cranberry Cocktail Sandwiches on Black Pepper & Sage Biscuits $3.50
Ham & Apple Cocktail Sandwiches on Black Pepper & Sage Biscuits $3.50
Door County Smoked Whitefish Salad on Cucumber Rounds $1.50
Bavarian Pretzels & Mustard Trio $3.50
Mini Fruit Skewers $2
Fresh Vietnamese Spring Rolls (meatless) $2.50
Vegetable Sushi Rolls $2.00
Fish Sushi Rolls $2.50
Gado Gado Platter of Steamed and Raw Vegetables with Spicy Peanut Sauce (50-75 servings) $175

Hot (requires staff on site):
Crispy Pomegranate Cigar $2.00
Venison Wellington $3.50
Chicken Satay $3.00
Local Nacho Bar $3.50
Spiced Corn Tartlet in Blue Corn Shell $2.50
Moroccan Lamb & Sweet Potato Tartlet $3.50
Metcalfe’s Signature Crab Cakes with Chili Remoulade $3.50

Finger Sweets:
Pumpkin Triangles $2
Chocolate Dipped Macaroons $2
Chocolate Chip Cookies $2
Cherry Almond Oat Cookies $2
Mini Assorted Buttercream Cupcakes $2.50
Truffles $2.50

We recommend serving 4-7 savory and 1-3 sweet items.



The Best Selection of Beef in Town!

  • Local & Sustainable

  • Kobe*

  • Prime

  • Dry-Aged*

  • Choice Black Angus

  • Grass-Fed

  • Organic

*Metcalfe’s Hilldale only.

Best in town?
You tell us!

Carl's Cakes

Contact our bakery department for all of our fabulous flavors and sizes, including local Carl’s Cakes at Hilldale.

Keep reusing your bags!

Money collected in our café tip jars is used to purchase reusable grocery bags that are donated to local schools, decorated by students and distributed for FREE on Earth Day.

Metcalfe’s Floral Studio guarantees more than 50 varieties of premium quality flowers and plants everyday (at grocery store prices)!

  • We Deliver
  • Open 24 Hours*
  • Walk-in Cooler*
  • 5-Day Flower Guarantee
  • Award-winning design

*Metcalfe’s Hilldale only.